Politifact: The debt limit fight: Why does it matter? How could it be resolved?

I spoke to Lou Jacobson for his Politifact post on the debt limit fight and how it might be resolved.

The White House could act unilaterally. The executive branch could mint a platinum coin with a face value of $1 trillion, deposit it in the Federal Reserve, and pay off its financial obligations as normal.

During a previous debt limit fight, Obama called the idea “wacky,” and in 2021, Yellen called it a “gimmick.” It’s also unclear whether this would be upheld in the courts.

Ironically, some Republicans might like to see Biden take this path, said Liam Donovan, a principal at the law firm Bracewell.

“It would absolve Republicans of any responsibility, while opening the door to political attacks on Biden’s extra-constitutional overreach,” Donovan said.

A fig leaf solution. The likeliest endgame, experts say, is that the two parties will negotiate a deal that raises the debt limit, but with conditions that Democrats can live with, such as “a good-faith, bipartisan reform to the process that can help Republicans save face without Biden looking like he paid a ransom,” Donovan said. “A small concession is the optimal path because it provides an offramp for the bulk of the Senate conference that doesn’t want a clean hike but also doesn’t have the stomach for going over the brink.”

This would leave lots of tough negotiating for consideration of spending bills later this year, but most observers say that’s a preferable outcome.

Read the full piece here.

Continue Reading

NYT: This Debt-Ceiling Fight Will Be Different

I participated in a roundtable discussion for the New York Times to discuss the Republican House majority and the coming clash over the federal debt limit. The TimesRoss Douthat led the conversation with me and my friend Haley Byrd Wilt of The Dispatch.

Here’s one of the key points I made:

Douthat: Let’s turn to the debt-ceiling issue. A lot of moderates and market watchers seem relatively sanguine, on the grounds that we’ve seen debt-ceiling fights before in the Obama era, and we know this will end (eventually) in compromise. But Liam, you’ve talked a lot about how there’s a big gulf between what conservatives consider the lessons of those Obama-era negotiations and how the Biden White House remembers them. Can you talk about those dueling visions?

Donovan: This is the fundamental problem at play — a mutual comfort level based on shared experiences from the not-so-distant past that the sides took very different lessons from.

For Republicans, the showdown in 2011 was the signal achievement of the Tea Party: staring down President Barack Obama and forcing the cuts associated with the Budget Control Act. It validated one of the animating forces of the right over the past decade-plus — that the party’s failures are a result of weak, feckless leadership, and if they fight, they win.

For Democrats, including Joe Biden, who as vice president had a front-row seat to the deal, it was evidence of why you should never negotiate under these circumstances, because it enables and encourages ever more reckless hostage-taking. That informs their current posture, as does the fact that they actually won the last such game of chicken in 2021.

Read the full piece here.

Continue Reading

Axios: Why debt ceiling risks could be real this time

I spoke to AxiosNeil Irwin about the debt limit collision course and the circular risk of market optimism and underreaction.

What they’re saying: “In order for Congress to act expeditiously, there must be a sense of gravity around the consequences should they fail to act,” Liam Donovan, a principal at Bracewell LLP, tells Axios.

•”At this point, conventional market wisdom is actively undermining that sort of pressure by projecting unmitigated confidence that it will all work out,” he said.

The bottom line: The sanguine outlook on Wall Street makes it more likely that some ugly days may be in store later this year.

Read the full piece here.

Continue Reading

Pro Politics with Zac McCrary

I joined veteran Democratic pollster Zac McCrary of Impact Research for the Pro Politics podcast, of which I am a longtime listener and fan.

Listen here and subscribe on all formats.

Show Notes

Liam Donovan, a principal at Bracewell PRG, is a regular presence on cable news, in print, and on twitter as an expert explainer of what’s going on in Congress and in the Republican Party. With a background both in GOP campaign politics and government relations, Liam’s expertise on the intersection of politics and policy gives him tremendous insight to distill what really matters in Washington from the rest of the Beltway din. In this conversation, we talk Liam’s path to politics, his time in GOP campaigns, his shift to government relations, and get his insights into the chaos of last week’s (eventual) ascent of Kevin McCarthy as House Speaker…what to expect from Congress over the next two years…and his early takes on Trump vs. DeSantis ’24 & the future of the Republican Party.

IN THIS EPISODE
Liam’s upbringing as a Navy Brat who went to high school in DC…

Liam’s stint working in GOP politics and at the NRSC…

The iconic GOP Senator Liam served as an aide to at the Senate committee…

Liam’s shift to government relations and lobbying…

Liam’s initial take on the chaotic House GOP process to anoint Kevin McCarthy as Speaker…

Liam on why it was probably inevitable for McCarthy to cave to the hard-right members…

Liam unpacks how McCarthy peeled off the different factions to earn the Speaker’s gavel…

Why the GOP center-right members never wavered for McCarthy…

Liam on why there was never a real chance of a few Republicans working with  Democrats to elect a coalition Speaker…

Liam’s thoughts on the risk McCarthy could be deposed mid-term…

The Trump impact on the Speaker’s race and the Trump-McCarthy relationship…

Liam analyzes the CLF / Freedom Caucus “truce”…

Liam’s insight on what to expect on the debt ceiling…

Liam’s early handicapping of Trump vs DeSantis 2024…

The origin story of Liam’s unusual twitter profile photo…

Liam shouts out one of his favorite twitter accounts…

Continue Reading